Getting a ruling like this from the 9th Circuit is pretty incredible. The evidence must have been QUITE clear.
"Throughout the ruling Tashima referred to Kowal’s ruling. He noted that “the ALJ issued a 36-page Decision that analyzed textbooks, curricular materials, and student work. The Decision also considered the testimony of state education officials, TUSD officials, teachers, parents, and education experts. After a fairly specific analysis of the evidence, the ALJ concluded that the evidence “establish[ed] that the MAS program has classes or courses designed for Latinos as a group, that promotes racial resentment against ‘Whites,’ and advocates ethnic solidarity of Latinos.”
Adios MAS…a good thing!