So what? Flat earthers still exist (at least nominally, there is some evidence they may just be trolling), and they are demonstrably wrong.
Neither can you know every detail of it. You’re lucky to get accurate ‘broad strokes’. You have no more idea what every early Christian believed than I do. You can tell us what the organizers of the most successful branches of the early church agreed would become their orthodoxy. The fact that it needed to dealt with in council would seem prima facie evidence that there was some controversy on it. What were the views of the patriarchs? Moses, Isaac, Jacob, Abraham, Adam? What’s the real ‘original idea’ you mention to Susanna? See Gen. 3 8, 17 1-21, 32 22-31 etc. That doesn’t read as phenomenological to me.
I’m telling you, as a p.s.a., what it looks like to someone who doesn’t even have any dogmatic assumptions to be ‘defended’. Nuts to your offense.
How’d that work out?
That is still him making assumptions of things that cannot be known to say what God is not.
I expect my quote tags are hosed. I seem to recall that multi-quoting has some kind of ritualistic mumbo-jumbo requirement, but I can’t recall exactly what it is…
EDIT: Nope, worked like a champ. IDK how I did that,though…