Would Hitler be Allowed to Join RO

Thats why I created this hypothetical thread, to make a point: If Hitler somehow magically came back to life and joined the forum, could we insult him? He is Hitler after all. Would insulting Hitler get you punished?

Yes, because it’s the content of the argument that matters, not the person.

That’s why there’s a devil’s advocate in the proceedings for declaring a saint; even the viewpoint of the actual Devil can have a point.

Ad hominem is a fallacy for a reason. Getting to insult people because someone equivocated them to Hitler sounds very much like the Left insisting they have a right to punch Nazis and decide who they are.

1 Like

ME: Would insulting Hitler get you punished?
AS: Yes, because it’s the content of the argument that matters, not the person.

There you go folks.
AS is now a Hitler defender.
Its not the person, after all. Those are AS words.
You are a bad person if you insult AS’s hero Uncle Adolf and you deserved to be punished if you insult Hitler. Thats Reality according to Adolf_Slim

AS = Adolf Slim

Hey AS, go fuck yourself. Hows that

Lol no.

Another leftist tactic. Guilt by association, guilt by insisting due process. Are you just copying them at this point?

1 Like

You already look like the ultimate idiot in this forum. Don’t make it worse by trying to paint me as a Leftist.

You come to the defense of Hitler, so I say go fuck yourself. Its as simple as that.

You are now ignored.

Adolf_Slim, protector and defender of Hitler
in his own words

Yes you do. You are unironically copying leftist tactics. This is exactly how they discredit people.

They play this very same Nazi game. Again, punching nazis.

I don’t know if you’re a leftist. I know you’re using their tactics.

That should make you stop and think.

Adolf_Slim, protector and defender of Hitler
in his own words

Nope, that’s just a leftist discredit tactic. I’m defending the rule, the person is irrelevant.

It’s dishonest btw. Why would a person in the right need to lie about someone else?

And here we come, full circle to the real failure of the current administration and ultimately the Republican party.

Trump does exactly what TT2 is doing. Making it personal. I admit that I engaged in a little back and fourth that was uncalled for. It was strangely cathartic given how easy it is to trigger the man, but in the end AS is right and given my honorary position as “the left” on this forum I think it better to hold myself to a higher standard and let TT2 display for all to see, the real failures of this administration.

Now ClassicalTeacher, in an offhanded way, has rebuked TT2 (unless she wishes to clarify her comment as support for TT2).

The next problem is that other members of this forum that have long observed the rules have failed to speak up and condemn TT2 and his actions in this forum (and to a lesser degree my own.

For my actions, I sincerely apologize to the members of this forum that I have come to know over the last 5 years. We’ve disagreed, sometimes even heatedly /*cough - looking at you PapaD :):wink:, but no one, to my knowledge has tried to turn this forum into this…

image

image

Is this what the forum is to become, one TT2 today, tomorrow it’s attracting all sorts easily triggered authoritarians who think the end always justify the means?

We don’t need an admin to speak up and let TT2 know this sort of thing isn’t appreciated.

While you’re at it, if you feel it’s necessary, feel free to condemn my own conduct, I know I’ve been out-of-line given what I’d like to see here.

That said, you can disagree with TT2 in no uncertain terms even if you agree with his ideology.

Let’s see who has the courage to stand up and say something…

@Sendgop @Caroline @qixlqatl @KenJackson

PapaD, RET?

It is duly noted that you are on the side of infanticide, socialism, government control, smashing Free Speech rights, giving free stuff to illegal aliens, and now they are the party of mobs in the streets burning and destroying cities.

It is duly noted that you are on the side of those who have polluted the minds of our children with homosexual and transgender filth and perversion and have destroyed every institution they have come into contact with from football to the boy scouts to even small churches.

It is duly noted that you are on the side of those who are burning cities and destroying art, murdering police and destroying the lives of all who dare disagree with them.

If this forum has sunk to a low it is because evil garbage like you are in it.

2 Likes

The old days of Dems v. GOP and the 8 year cycle of switching who is in power are over. They are dead and buried. We are now in a life or death battle between good and evil, Socialism and Americanism.

I am on the side of good
csbrown, and now it would seem adolf_slim, are on the side of evil.

As I said: Liberals today They have polluted the minds of our children with homosexual and transgender filth and perversion. They have destroyed every institution they have come into contact with from football to the boy scouts to even small churches… They are burning cities and destroying art, they are murdering police and destroying the lives of all who dare disagree with them. They have imposed fascist edicts on us the violate our constitutional rights. They tried to overthrow the government with a faux impeachment.

They embrace infanticide - not abortion, infanticide. They HATE GOD and spit on all that Christ taught.

They cannot be dealt with, they must be destroyed, utterly.

Not one person here except for CS AS would disagree with that assessment of today’s situation. So I reserve the right to call out any degenerate who supports these evils, and those degenerates just posted right above me

Going to disagree here, it’s not “leftist”, though certainly people on the left engage in this behavior, but a human trait that people engage in, especially those that feel they have reached a plateau of moral superiority and use that to justify and rationalize bad behavior.

Since you so often portray yourself as a man of logic and facts (sometimes quite effectively), I might ask, do you have a justification for calling this a “leftist tactic”, or did you just use the term as a pejorative in an attempt to shame TT2 into seeing the hypocrisy of his own behavior?

And you have done it with me too. I am fed up with you.

The best your party can do is to nominate a man who is totally unqualified to be President. His mind is gone, and he will have to resign for the good of country, within three months, which is my prediction. That means when you vote for him, you are voting in Harris as president.

Harris fills a racial and gender quota. Just like almost every African-American was barred from getting many jobs before the mid 1960s, every White person in the Democratic Party was barred from from the vice presidential nomination and de facto election as President. Now, who are the racists and the sexists?

Harris has a voting record in Senate that is to the left of Bernie Sanders. She has been inconsistent in her views for her entire public life. I would compare her to Nixon. There is nothing honest there. Just blind ambition, like Hillary Clinton.

You claim that Trump has failed at everything. You know that’s crap, but it makes you feel superior to the conservatives and Republicans which you hate with a passion. You are offended by what @TrumpTrain2 has written about you. You need someone to save your little snowflake ego. Well the cavalry is not going arrive in time to save you.

You can take it or leave. Frankly I’m not going to miss you if you do. I’ve had much worse stuff thrown at me on other sites, and my reaction is to ignore that person completely. Political dialog is dead in this country, and people like you have made it that way.

3 Likes

There is no end to your lies and misdirection. It was just a few days ago that you were distancing yourself from the socialist baby-killers. You were saying “Just because others are evil does not make me evil.” Now you flip the script and say it is about you.

I am going to say this again so that even a child can understand it:

Your party promotes and endorses evil.
You promote and endorse and defend your party.
Ergo, you promote and endorse evil and therefore you ARE evil.

Its simple. It is so simple. You can snivel and cry and post all your lies and stupidities, but that’s it. Its not even up for debate. You promote evil and you ARE evil.

There is just one thing that I don’t understand: Why don’t you own it. You are like a homo who has sex with men, lives with men, kisses men in public, but refuses to say he is gay. I would probably attack you less if you just came out of your closet and embraced your inner Hitler. You are not fooling anyone here. Just own it.

Here is what I want you to say:

I, csbrown28, am on the side of the party of infanticide, socialism, government control, smashing Free Speech rights, giving free stuff to illegal aliens.

I, csbrown28, am on the side of those who have introduced children to homosexual and transgender acceptance.

I, csbrown28, am on the side of those who are burning cities and destroying art, and murdering police.

Just say it. We all know it. You know it. Just say it.

.

Yep.

Of course, we all have, but have I called you an asshole or told you “fuck yourself”? Or aren’t you capable of making a distinction?

And?

Of course, fear that Harris is the MOST radical of radicals…lol

No, I’ve said that he has succeeded in a few places, but he will be remembered as the great divider.

LOL, he’s the one that get’s triggered, not me (evidenced by his hate-filled rants and constantly repeating himself). I don’t care if he calls me names, really I could care less, but I doubt the community here would put up with a liberal on this site acting as he does. I guess I gave you too much credit as a man of principle. I thought you of all people could point out that TT2’s tactics aren’t constant with the principles that I would have thought you would have claimed for yourself, but no surprise, hypocrisy.

Right, it’s me…lol

Then why do you explode over someone simply disagreeing with you?

Your arguments nor your methods are beyond criticism because you’re still human. You don’t get to be free of critique.

Even if your ideas are the right ideas, they can be emphasized the wrong way. That’s what the left has gotten wrong with anti-rascism.

That’s what the right got wrong about Iraq. Turns out as good as democratic and liberty-loving principles are, you can’t just push their adoption through force. You have to wait for the desire for them to emerge on their own.

1 Like

You have obviously lost sight of how this began. I understand. You are not too bright.

I never exploded. You just love your lies and misdirections don’t you.

This all started because I called browneye some names, and I defended myself because he is evil and he deserves them.

I have since proven that he supports pure evil, and I have demonstrated that anyone who supports and promotes and defends evil must necessarily be evil themselves, and therefore I am justified in any name I call him.

This has taken place over the course of several days and scores of posts, maybe even over a hundred posts.

Obviously this is all above your head because you yourself support many of the same evils.

Now, shaddup and go away.

I say ad hominem is a well known fallacy, you respond with “go fuck yourself”.

I didn’t swear, I didn’t insult you. You jumped to that.

That’s not reality.

Defense attornies exist to defend everyone, even serial killers. Even those worse than that.

When we put the planners of the 9/11 attacks on trial, we provided them with defense attornies.

The Nazis at the Nuremberg trials equally were provided defense attornies.

Letting even outright perpetrators of evil speak for themselves and have a proper defense is a principle within our society. Justice doesn’t function by condemning people unilaterally. Nor does virtue.

Nor does sense making.

This sounds like an attempt to satisfy a feeling, not a principle. Principally, nothing in the real world says this is permissible.

The Bible doesn’t say that, the Catechism doesn’t say that. Nothing within Catholicism approves of this.

This can’t be reconciled with “turn the other cheek” or appeals to meekness. “Hate the sin, not the sinner” as the saying goes.

1 Like

Perhaps. But we call out the sinner all the same.

And yet he cries like a a girl about it all the time.

Here is what I want you to say:

I, csbrown28, am on the side of the party of infanticide, socialism, government control, smashing Free Speech rights, giving free stuff to illegal aliens.

I, csbrown28, am on the side of those who have introduced children to homosexual and transgender acceptance.

I, csbrown28, am on the side of those who are burning cities and destroying art, and murdering police.

Just say it. We all know it. You know it. Just say it.

Pappadave knows it.

Sendgop knows you have screwed up the dialog here.

You are just an agitator who supports, defends and promotes evil

And by the way, I am not triggered and I am not exploding. I am sitting in a comfy chair, relaxed, typing the truth. If you want triggered and exploding go hang out with you mobs who are burning and looting and killing cops and destroying property - those are YOUR people, those are the triggered exploding mobs you support. Another lie of yours and Adolf-Slim’s exposed.

I don’t take Bible lessons from lying freaks like you.